Dont Throw Your Trash in My Backyard

Garbage Bins Sealed Shut

I had originally intended to go with a different post for today’s Toronto Uncovered, however, the recent decision for Toronto’s city workers to go on strike deserves priority.

Starting today, many services and facilities in Toronto will come to a screeching halt. The most noticeable of these will be the garbage collection of all Toronto residents and businesses. For those who remember how horrible it was to be in Toronto during the last garbage strike 7 years ago (Toronto Garbage Strike 2002), you’ll agree it was NOT pretty. I lived in the Annex at the time and remember literally walk2002 Garbage Strikeing over mounds of garbage stock-piled on the streets, and watching mice and other vermin scurry about. The smell was nothing to gloss over either.  Friends living in China Town stayed with us to escape the filth of their neighbourhood. The strike eventually ended two weeks later when Ontario lawmakers forced workers back to their jobs due severe health concerns. The Pope’s scheduled pilgrimage to Toronto that summer also helped push legislation through, as the city needed to be cleaned for the arrival of the thousands of tourists.

From all the on and offline discussions I had this past weekend, I can tell you that the garbage strike was definitely on the minds of many Torontonians. Most people couldn’t understand how a city the magnitude of Toronto could allow this to happen again, especially in the wake of pandemics, epidemics, and other health concerns. I would hope that hygiene and disease control would be top priorities for all city officials as we enter into the hot summer months.

I am an avid user of Twitter and one of Mayor David Miller’s many followers.  One would hope that the looming strike would have been a top priority for him over the weekend.  I was really disappointed to Miller Ribbon Cuttingsee his weekend tweets updating followers about his fathers day gift, and his attendance at various TFC games, picnics, ribbon cuttings, and NXNE events. Sounds like he was having a pretty good little weekend while the rest of us were stressing about potential garbage strikes, park closures, day care and summer camp closures, and lack of transportation to and from Toronto Island (putting many businesses who depend on ferry traffic in the red).  I was surprised to read  this morning’s National Post where Miller was quoted saying, “While we will continue to negotiate with the union locals during a strike, I want residents and businesses to know that we are working in their interests to protect the future of services in our city”. I am still unclear when all this “work” was being done – he must be quite the multi-tasker.

I am not typically a supporter of unions. I feel that since the introduction of the Human Rights Act, most have become outdated and unnecessary in contemporary society.  I believe that if you are unhappy with your job, your earnings or allotted vacation time you should either negotiate with your current employer or start looking elsewhere – just like the rest of us un-unionized folk. If I have a problem with my workplace, I probably wouldn’t get very far by threatening not to come in. That said, it seems the city got themselves into this mess (again), and they will now need to get themselves (and the rest of us) out of it. A majority of other municipalities contract garbage services to private companies to eliminate the possibility of a strike and save money at the same time. Why didn’t Toronto learn from past mistakes and take necessary actions to ensure public health and safety was upheld? Negotiations have been on the table for six months without resolution. How can that be? In six months, the US can elect and swear in their first black president, Wall Street can crumble beneath its own feet and begin to rebuild, and the landscape of the global economy can change forever.  So, my question is: How “hard” were our city negotiators really working?

I understand that city politics are not always cut and dry, especially when unions are involved, but this is unacceptable and inexcusable. Bring on municipal elections!

7 Responses to “Dont Throw Your Trash in My Backyard”

  • I generally like Mayor Miller and even had a great conversation with him and his wife on the TTC after a Toronto FC game last year (he didn’t even seem to mind I had a couple Carlsbergs in me)! But your point about his tweeting over the weekend is an interesting one. Whenever these things happen in cities, leaders always assure us of their diligent work to resolve the situation, but it seems Mayor Miller, in this instance, has caught himself red handed. An interesting side effect of his effort to be transparent with citizens…
    That all said, unions are extremely powerful entities. Imagine if the collective efforts of thousands of people over a number of decades (even before you were born) could’ve helped negotiate your contract for your current job?!? While I’m certainly no expert on the issue, because the city and the union are such massive, complex and bureaucratic entities, it takes an even larger force (like the Pope, as an example) to force them to put aside their politicking and sit down to come to a speedy resolution.
    With no such intervention on the horizon, I imagine we’re in for a needlessly long, frustrating strike that will never make sense to any of us who aren’t directly involved. Happily, the government will lose too much money to allow the LCBO strike to go on for too long, so at least we’ll have liquor to get us through…
    My biggest question though – why do these garbage strikes always have to happen in the summer??? Hopefully the garbage doesn’t pile up too badly at the beach…

  • hmorrison:

    Good points. I don’t think Miller is a bad guy, but I have had my doubts for a long time that he is capable of leading our city. As for unions – you’re absolutely correct, they are RIDICULOUSLY powerful, many would argue too powerful. They were necessary in society before the introduction of basic human rights and employment law, however, today they often look to secure deals based on an inflated sense of entitlement – I would LOVE to have 18 sick days on top of my already allotted vacation and personal days. After six months at the bargaining tables, you would hope the government and union could come to an agreement. Moving forward, I hope we look towards privatizing this service (or making it an essential service, removing their right to strike).

    LCBO is going to be BUSY tonight!

  • I really like your idea of privatizing the service, but I’m sure the unions contracts block that as well. There’s a lot of unemployed people out there right now who would happily take those wages/sick days/etc but can’t. More than the garbage on our streets and the frustration with leadership, I think the biggest shame is that we’re in a horrible recession and those who have are demanding more while so many would be ecstatic to take the wage these unions are striking against.
    I think I might use the LCBO strike as an excuse to take a break from drinking… it’s been a long summer already….

  • hmorrison:

    Im not sure what kind of clauses the unions have around privatization – i do know that nearly 50% of all US cities contract out all or some of their garbage collection, and end up saving money in the process. Sigh, we need to get with the times and stop being so lenient. You hit the nail on the head: we are in tough times, there are cut backs in all work places across all industries, now is not the time to ask for more more more, when highly qualified people are worrying about how they will provide for themselves and families. Unions need to pick their fights more wisely.

  • Bullies don’t tend to do that…

  • Daniel Dorsey:

    The more I think about the Toronto services strike, the more I believe that Mayor Miller is trying to break the union. Enterprising young businesspeople are picking up garbage and hauling it away for a fee. These entrepreneurs new the strike was going to happen a while ago, and that is precisely when I started getting e-mail’s and flyers about hauling away my garbage for $5 per bag. They all seem to charge $5 per bag. How do they all arrive at this price?

    Perhaps this is new landscape for Toronto. The micro business is alive and well. I for one, am sick of the unions holding the city hostage every two to three years (the average time between strikes that hit the city). The TTC, Toronto Services, Maintenance workers, Teachers, etc… We certainly need some sort of municipal ‘back to work’ legislation.

    As citizens we all need to cooperate and share in the spoils. In these tough economic times, I am expecting my fellow citizens in the Toronto Services department to think about their brethren out there looking for employment. Since the strikers are not thinking about us, maybe Mayor Miller is by giving entrepreneurs the chance to take over the city disposal contracts. If these are his thoughts and strategies, more power to Mayor MIller.

  • David Miller:

    I dump my garbage in the street

    Near non-existent garbage pick up despite the crippling taxes we pay + bins so small they can barely hold a days worth of trash for a typical family + garbage reeking in the house while waiting the two weeks for pick up + everything available in the stores is overpackaged to begin with = throwing my garbage in the street

    You should too

    We paid through the nose for those overpaid city workers, might as well give them something to do

Leave a Reply

  • Best ride in the Distillery District
    I don’t make it out to the Distillery District as much as I’d like to. I know there are tons of cool shops, restaurants and galleries to explore, but being a  West end girl I usually only travel to the East side for a reason. A couple months I went to support the relaunch of Hoi […]
  • Fleas Are Fabulous!
    In recent years, the faux-vintage indie scene appears to have taken our city by storm.  I cite the replacement of many funky Queen Street shops, specifically between Spadina and University, with chain stores like H&M and Urban Outfitters as my evidence. Don’t get me wrong, I like both those stores but I miss the authentic […]
  • Summer Basics
    Every spring I do a big shop for my summer basics: plain tees, tank tops, beach shorts, sandals and summer shoes. I’m not picky, the clothes need to last at least one season and be reasonably priced, that way if something happens to them, it really doesn’t matter. Year after year I find myself in […]
  • Hercules and Love Affair Love Toronto
    If Summer is the season in which lust and love are allowed to run rampant, Hercules and Love Affair is the perfect accent to Summer’s seduction. I went to see them play at Mod Club Monday night, and was thoroughly entranced. I had a vague idea of what to expect: I had watched them on […]
  • Dance The Night Away
    I’ve never been one to turn down a good dance party, hell, I throw my own dance parties for one whenever I am lucky enough to have my condo to myself. I love house music, I love playing it loud, and I love to dance. This weekend I went to one such dance party at […]
  • Moon Walker: Michael Jakson Tribute
    Thursday night I went to Clinton’s to see my ridiculously talented younger brother, Alex St. Kitts, perform Moon Walker: A Michael Jackson Tribute. I lived with him for 4 years and listened to endless bass and vocals practice, so I never doubted his talent. That said, I had no idea he could rip up the […]
Subscribe